Short answer
Simple payback is the installed cost divided by the yearly saving after running costs. For a factory it depends mostly on the avoidable cost per unit on your bill (the saving on each unit the plant supplies), then on the yield and the installed cost. Check those three numbers in any quote and most of the difference between vendors explains itself.
Key takeaways
- Simple payback = what the plant costs ÷ what it saves each year. Every input can be checked against your own bills.
- The biggest lever is the avoidable cost per unit. It is usually lower than the average tariff on your bill, because fixed and demand charges stay.
- A ₹1 change in avoidable cost per unit moves payback by months, so get that number right before you compare quotes.
- Payback ignores everything after the break-even year. Over a plant’s working life, IRR tells you more.
What simple payback measures, and what it leaves out
Simple payback is the number of years a solar plant takes to save what it cost. Boards usually ask for it first, and it is the easiest figure to check: it needs only the installed cost and one year of saving.
Simple payback (years) = installed cost ÷ (annual saving − annual O&M cost)
Its weakness is what it leaves out. A plant runs for about 25 years and payback stops counting at break-even, so two plants with the same payback can have very different lifetime value. Use it to sense-check a quote, then judge the investment on IRR (the yearly return over the plant’s life).
Five inputs behind every payback figure
1. Avoidable cost per unit
Each solar unit replaces a unit you would have bought from your distribution company (DISCOM), so it saves the per-unit charges on your bill: the energy charge and per-unit additions such as fuel adjustment charges, plus duties levied per unit. It does not save fixed or demand charges. This is usually lower than the average rate you get by dividing the bill by the units, and it is the most common reason a payback looks better on paper than in practice. Our guide to reading your bill shows how to find it.
2. Generation per kWp
How many units each kWp produces in a year depends on where the plant is, its tilt and orientation, shading and how well it is maintained. Ask for the yield estimate and the tool behind it; you can check the order of magnitude for your location on the Global Solar Atlas.
3. How much of that generation you use
Units you consume on site are worth the full avoidable cost. Units exported to the grid, or lost to export limits on weekends and holidays, are worth whatever your state’s metering rules give for them, which is often less. Size the plant to your daytime load.
4. Installed cost
Cost per kWp varies with roof type, structure, module and inverter choice, plant size and site access. Compare quotes on the same specification, including the structure and safety items that cheaper quotes sometimes leave out.
5. Running costs
Cleaning, preventive maintenance, monitoring, insurance and the eventual inverter replacement. A payback figure that assumes no running cost is optimistic.
Payback for a 1 MWp plant on a factory roof
Assumptions
- Installed cost ₹40,000 per kWp, so ₹4 crore
- 1,300 kWh per kWp a year, so 13,00,000 units, all used on site
- Avoidable cost ₹8.00 per unit; O&M ₹500 per kWp a year
- Gross saving
- ₹1.04 crore
- Less O&M
- ₹5 lakh
- Net saving in year one
- ₹99 lakh
- Simple payback, before tax
- 4.0 years
This is before tax benefits and tariff escalation, which raise the return. For a profitable company, 40% depreciation at a 25.17% tax rate also cuts year-one tax by ₹40.27 lakh, which shortens the after-tax payback.
Assumed figures to show the method. Not a quote and not a result from any Adhvanik plant.
Which input moves payback most
The same plant, with the two inputs that move most. Each cell is simple payback before tax, at 1,300 kWh per kWp and O&M of ₹500 per kWp a year:
| Avoidable cost | ₹35,000 / kWp | ₹40,000 / kWp | ₹45,000 / kWp |
|---|---|---|---|
| ₹6.00 per unit | 4.8 years | 5.5 years | 6.2 years |
| ₹7.00 per unit | 4.1 years | 4.7 years | 5.2 years |
| ₹8.00 per unit | 3.5 years | 4.0 years | 4.5 years |
| ₹9.00 per unit | 3.1 years | 3.6 years | 4.0 years |
Read across a row: a ₹5,000 per kWp difference in price moves payback by 5 to 8 months. Read down a column: each rupee of avoidable cost per unit moves it by 5 to 11 months. That is why the first job is to pin down your own avoidable cost, and why a cheaper plant that generates less is rarely the bargain it looks.
Why IRR tells you more than payback
IRR counts every year of savings over the plant’s life, the timing of tax benefits and any tariff escalation, and turns them into one rate you can compare with your cost of capital. Two things to keep in view:
- Savings continue long after payback, as long as the plant is maintained. Module output declines slowly with age, which a good model includes.
- Downtime and underperformance come straight out of the return. A plant that runs at a lower performance ratio pays back later; see our guide to performance ratio.
Our CAPEX projects return 25%+ IRR. A Pune plant returned 50%+ IRR and paid back in under 2 years. Your own figure depends on your tariff, roof and load, which is what a feasibility study works out.
Five checks on a vendor’s payback figure
Which avoidable cost per unit did you use, and which bill lines does it include?
If it is the average tariff including fixed charges, the saving is overstated.
What yield per kWp did you assume, from which tool, and with what losses?
A generous yield assumption is the quickest way to shorten a payback on paper.
How much of the generation will we consume, month by month?
Exported or curtailed units are worth less than units used on site.
What running costs are included, and is inverter replacement in the model?
Leaving out O&M or replacements flatters the figure.
Is the payback before or after tax, and with or without tariff escalation?
Compare like with like across quotes.
Our free 7-day feasibility study puts your own bills and roof through this model. It includes a financial ROI sheet based on a preliminary design, a policy check for your state and connection and a roof feasibility and the area available for installation.
Sources
Policy and tax rules change. Facts below were checked in Nov 2026; confirm the version in force for your state and tax year before you sign.
- Global Solar Atlas (World Bank Group / Solargis): site-level PV output estimates (opens in a new tab). check expected kWh per kWp for your coordinates
- India Briefing: Understanding accelerated depreciation of solar power assets in India (Feb 2024) (opens in a new tab)
- PIB (Ministry of Finance): The Income Tax Act, 2025 to come into effect from 1 April 2026 (opens in a new tab)
