Financing guide

CAPEX or PPA: which solar model fits your factory?

Ownership, tax, risk and savings side by side, with the five questions that settle it for most factories.

Short answer

Choose CAPEX if you own the site, plan to stay and have taxable profit to use the depreciation: you keep the whole saving and carry the performance risk. Choose a PPA if your capital earns more elsewhere or you lease the building: you invest nothing and pay only for the units the plant generates. Many groups use both.

Key takeaways

  • CAPEX: you pay for the plant, own it and keep every unit of saving. PPA / OPEX: the developer pays and owns it, and you buy its power per unit.
  • The choice turns on your cost of capital, whether you can use the depreciation, and how long you will stay at the site.
  • Per unit, CAPEX saves more. A PPA saves less per unit but needs no capital, so compare cash flow, with the tariff as one input.
  • Many companies use both: CAPEX where they own the building and plan to stay, a PPA where they lease or want capital elsewhere.

CAPEX means you buy the plant; a PPA means you buy the power

The plant on your roof is the same either way: the same modules, inverters and structure. What changes is who pays for it, who owns it and how you are billed.

CAPEX. You buy the plant outright, usually through an EPC contract (engineering, procurement and construction: one company designs and builds it). It is your asset from commissioning. Every unit it generates displaces a unit you would have bought from your distribution company (DISCOM), so the whole saving is yours. So is the job of keeping the plant running, normally through an O&M contract (operations and maintenance).

PPA / OPEX (also called the RESCO model). A developer invests in the plant, owns it and operates it on your premises. You sign a power purchase agreement and pay an agreed tariff for each unit the plant generates, typically for 5–25 years. Your saving is the gap between that tariff and the grid charge it replaces.

CAPEX and a PPA compared, row by row

General comparison. Contract terms vary; your agreement sets the final position.
Compared onCAPEXPPA / OPEX
Upfront capitalFull plant costNone
Who owns the plantYou, from commissioningThe developer, for the PPA term
Saving per unitThe full grid charge you avoid, less O&MGrid charge minus the PPA tariff
DepreciationYours to claimThe developer’s; it shapes the tariff
Performance riskYours, managed through the O&M contractThe developer’s: it is paid only for units generated
CommitmentNone after purchase, beyond O&MA long-term PPA (5–25 years) with exit terms
SuitsOwned sites, taxable profits, spare capitalLeased sites, capital needed elsewhere

Five questions that decide between CAPEX and a PPA

1. What does your capital earn elsewhere?

A CAPEX plant is an investment with a return. If the money would earn more in a new production line or in paying down expensive debt, a PPA lets you take the solar saving without diverting it. If capital is idle or cheap, owning the plant usually wins. Ask for the plant’s project IRR, the yearly return it earns over its life, and compare it with your hurdle rate, the minimum return you accept on any investment. A bank deposit is the wrong benchmark.

2. Can you use the depreciation?

Solar power generating systems have sat in the 40% written-down-value block of India’s income-tax depreciation schedule: each year you deduct 40% of the cost not yet written off, so most of the deduction lands in the first years (see accelerated depreciation). That deduction only helps if you have taxable profit to set it against. A company with carried-forward losses gets little from it in the early years, and the PPA developer, who can use the benefit, may be the better owner. The Income-tax Act, 2025 replaced the 1961 Act from 1 April 2026, so confirm the rate and conditions for your tax year with your adviser.

3. How long will you be at this site?

A plant lasts about 25 years. If you own the building and expect to stay, both models work. If you lease, check whether the lease outlasts the payback (for CAPEX) or the PPA term, and what the landlord allows on the roof.

4. Who will look after the plant?

Under a PPA, the developer is paid only for units generated, so it has every reason to keep the plant running. Under CAPEX, that discipline has to come from your O&M contract: uptime and performance guarantees, response times and what you are paid when they are missed.

5. Does it have to sit on your balance sheet?

A CAPEX plant is a fixed asset. A PPA is a purchase of power, but its accounting depends on the contract: ask your auditor whether it must be treated as a lease under Ind AS 116 before you assume it stays off the balance sheet.

Year one for a 1 MWp plant, under each model

The same 1 MWp plant, first year only, before any tariff escalation or degradation:

Illustrative example1 MWp rooftop plant: CAPEX vs PPA in year one

Assumptions

  • Generation 1,300 kWh per kWp a year, so 13,00,000 units
  • Grid charge avoided ₹8.00 per unit; PPA tariff ₹4.50 per unit
  • CAPEX cost ₹40,000 per kWp (₹4 crore); O&M ₹5 lakh a year
  • Tax rate 25.17%; depreciation at 40% in year one
CAPEX: saving after O&M
₹99 lakh
CAPEX: capital invested
₹4 crore
CAPEX: year-one depreciation
₹1.6 crore
CAPEX: tax reduced by that depreciation
₹40.27 lakh
PPA: saving (grid charge − tariff)
₹45.5 lakh
PPA: capital invested
₹0

CAPEX saves about 2.2 times as much each year, but needs ₹4 crore up front. The PPA saving needs no capital at all.

Assumed figures to show the method. Not a quote and not a result from any Adhvanik plant.

Neither number settles it on its own. The CAPEX case improves with every year the plant runs after it has paid for itself, and depreciation moves tax savings forward rather than adding new money. The PPA case is the saving you get while your capital works elsewhere. Set the CAPEX return against your hurdle rate, and the PPA saving against zero investment.

Our CAPEX projects return 25%+ IRR. A Pune plant returned 50%+ IRR and paid back in under 2 years. Your own figure depends on your tariff, roof and load, which is what a feasibility study works out.

You can run CAPEX at one site and a PPA at another

You do not have to choose once for the whole company. Some of our clients run CAPEX plants at some factories and PPA plants at others. A common split is CAPEX where the company owns the building and plans to stay, and a PPA at leased sites or where capital is committed to expansion. If neither fits, a financial lease or EMI spreads the cost of an owned plant over a few years; see our financing options.

Five questions to put to any vendor, including us

  1. Show me the CAPEX and PPA cases for my site on the same assumptions.

    Comparing a CAPEX quote from one firm with a PPA quote from another mixes different yields, tariffs and escalation rates.

  2. Is the PPA tariff fixed for the term, or does it escalate?

    A small yearly escalation compounds over the term and can erase the gap to your grid tariff in later years.

  3. What is the buy-out price in each year, and how is it calculated?

    It decides what flexibility you have if your plans change.

  4. What generation does the PPA commit to, and what happens if it falls short?

    A PPA without a generation commitment leaves you buying grid power when the plant underperforms.

  5. Who carries the O&M, insurance and roof-repair costs in each model?

    These sit in different places in each contract and change the real cost.

What our feasibility study gives you

Our free 7-day feasibility study gives you a financial ROI sheet based on a preliminary design, a policy check for your state and connection, roof feasibility and a budgetary quote. Under a PPA we run the plant for the whole term; under CAPEX you can contract our in-house O&M team, on contracts of up to 25 years.

Sources

Policy and tax rules change. Facts below were checked in Nov 2026; confirm the version in force for your state and tax year before you sign.

  1. PIB (Ministry of Finance): The Income Tax Act, 2025 to come into effect from 1 April 2026 (opens in a new tab)
  2. India Briefing: Understanding accelerated depreciation of solar power assets in India (Feb 2024) (opens in a new tab). 40% written-down-value rate for solar power generating systems under the 1961 Act

Common questions

Depreciation, buy-outs and exits under a PPA

Short answers. The working is in the guide above.

Compare CAPEX and PPA for your factory
Is a PPA always more expensive than CAPEX?

Per unit over the life of the plant, usually yes, because the developer earns a return on the capital it puts in. But a PPA needs no capital from you, so the right comparison is the saving per rupee you invest, and in a PPA that rupee stays in your business.

Who claims accelerated depreciation under a PPA?

The owner of the plant. Under a PPA that is the developer, so the tax benefit is part of how the developer prices the tariff. Under CAPEX it is yours.

Can we buy the plant during a PPA?

Many PPAs include a buy-out option at set points in the term, with a price schedule agreed at signing. Read that schedule before you sign, not when you want to exercise it.

What happens to a PPA if we move out of the building?

It depends on the exit clause. Typical options are relocating the plant, transferring the PPA to the new occupant or paying a termination amount. If a move is likely, negotiate this first.

Free feasibility study

Get an ROI sheet for your plant

The feasibility study is free, takes 7 days and carries no commitment. An engineer replies within 48 hours.

What the study covers

  • Financial ROI sheet based on a preliminary design
  • Policy check for your state and connection
  • Roof feasibility and the area available for installation
Call us+91 22 4618 3484Get a free feasibility study