CAPEX saves more over the plant's life; OPEX needs no capital
CAPEX (capital expenditure: you pay for the plant) gives you the largest saving over the plant's life, because once the plant has paid for itself the power costs you only its upkeep. OPEX gives you a smaller saving with no capital at all, because the developer's return is built into the tariff. Neither is better in general; the right choice depends on your balance sheet and your plans for the site.
Three questions that decide it
1. What else could the capital earn?
If money spent on a new line or a debt repayment earns more than the plant would, keep it there and choose OPEX. If you have surplus cash or cheap debt, owning the plant usually wins.
2. Can you use the depreciation?
An owner can claim accelerated depreciation on the plant, but the tax shield is worth something only if the company has taxable profits to set it against. A loss-making unit gets little from it.
3. How long will you stay at the site?
A PPA runs for many years and is tied to the roof. If the site may be sold, leased out or closed, check the exit terms first. An owned plant can be moved, at a cost.
You can use both
Groups with several factories often own the plants at sites they own outright and sign PPAs at leased or newer sites. There is no rule against mixing the two models across a portfolio.
Comparison
Side by side
How the two models compare on the points finance teams ask about.
| Compared on | CAPEX (you own) | OPEX / PPA (developer owns) |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Full plant price | None |
| Monthly payment | Upkeep and insurance only | Tariff × units generated |
| Savings profile | Largest over the plant life, after payback | Smaller, from the first bill |
| Performance risk | Yours, shared through an O&M contract | The developer's |
| Depreciation | Yours to claim | The developer's |
| Best when | You have capital and a long future at the site | Capital is better used elsewhere |
Mistakes we see in comparisons
- Comparing a CAPEX payback period with a PPA tariff: compare the net present value of the savings from each over the same period (their worth in today's rupees), and test the CAPEX IRR against your own hurdle rate, the minimum return you accept on any investment
- Leaving O&M, insurance and inverter replacement out of the CAPEX case
- Ignoring the PPA escalation clause when projecting tariffs
- Counting depreciation benefits the company cannot use this year
- Forgetting exit costs if the site may change hands
How we help you choose
Our CAPEX projects return 25%+ IRR. A Pune plant returned 50%+ IRR and paid back in under 2 years. Under CAPEX: you own the plant from commissioning. Under PPA / OPEX: Adhvanik invests, owns and runs the plant. Our free feasibility study (7 days, no commitment) includes a financial ROI sheet based on a preliminary design.
